Do I Need a Tub or a Shower? A Homeowner’s Guide from Total Bath

Remodeling your bathroom should feel exciting—not overwhelming. But once you hit the “tub vs. shower” fork in the road, it can start to feel like you’re choosing between form and function. Relax! At Total Bath, we’ve helped hundreds of homeowners navigate this exact choice.

Whether you're renovating a master suite, updating the kids’ bathroom, or finally upgrading the guest bath, let’s break down the pros, cons, and practical factors to help you confidently choose between a tub or a shower.

🚿 The Case for a Shower

✅ Why Homeowners Love Showers:

• Space-Saving Superstars: Showers are ideal for small bathrooms. If you're working with limited space, a sleek walk-in or corner shower can make the room feel bigger and more open.
• Accessibility Wins: Showers, especially curbless or low-threshold models, are more accessible for people with mobility issues.
• Modern & Minimalist: Let’s be honest, showers can look downright stunning. Think seamless glass enclosures, rainfall showerheads, and luxe tile work.
• Faster Routines: Showers are quick and convenient—perfect for busy mornings.

⚠️ A Few Considerations:

• Resale Value Risks: Some buyers see a home without at least one tub as a deal-breaker, especially families with small kids.
• No Soak Zone: If you love relaxing in a hot bath, a shower just won’t scratch that itch.

🛁 The Case for a Tub

✅ Why Homeowners Still Choose Tubs:

• Bath Time Bliss: If you’ve got kids—or just love a good soak—a tub is unbeatable. There’s a reason bubble baths never go out of style.
• Luxury Factor: Freestanding tubs are a statement. Whether it’s a clawfoot classic or a modern oval, they instantly elevate a bathroom’s vibe.
• Boosts Resale Appeal: Many realtors suggest keeping at least one tub in the home, especially in family-friendly neighborhoods.

⚠️ Think Twice If:

• You’re Short on Space: Tubs take up more room—period. In tight bathrooms, they can feel bulky or crowd the layout.
• You Rarely Use It: If your current tub is collecting dust and bath bombs you never use, why keep it?

🤔 So… Which One Is Right for You?

Ask yourself:

• Do you actually use your current tub—or is it just taking up space?
• Will you eventually need more accessible design features?
• Is this your forever home, or are you thinking about resale?
• What does your routine look like—quick rinse or long soak?

Still unsure? Sometimes the best answer is… both! If your layout allows, combining a tub and a shower (either in separate zones or a tub-shower combo) gives you ultimate flexibility.

🛠️ Total Bath Pro Tip: Think Long-Term

At Total Bath, we always encourage homeowners to think beyond just what looks good today. Consider how your needs might change in 5, 10, or 15 years. A gorgeous tub is great, but if you're planning to stay in your home as you age, a walk-in shower might save you a remodel down the line.

👨‍🔧 How We Can Help at Total Bath

We’re not just here to install tile and fixtures. We help you build a bathroom that suits your lifestyle, matches your budget, and fits your aesthetic goals. Our team will walk through your current layout, hear your needs, and show you exactly what’s possible in your space.

🧠 FAQs – Because You’ve Got Questions!

Q: Is it bad for resale to remove my only tub?

A: It depends. If it’s your only full bath and you're in a family-oriented area, buyers might expect a tub. But if it's your master or guest bath, a shower-only space can still add value with the right design.

Q: Are walk-in showers safe for seniors?

A: Absolutely. In fact, many seniors prefer them. We can add grab bars, built-in seating, and non-slip tile for added safety.

Q: Which option is cheaper?

A: Generally, showers are more affordable—especially if you’re going with a prefab insert. Custom tile work and freestanding tubs can hike up the price tag.

🔍 Wrap-Up: Your Bathroom, Your Way

At the end of the day, there’s no wrong answer—just the right one for you. Whether you're a quick-shower-on-the-go type or a candlelit-soak enthusiast, your bathroom should reflect your needs and style.

If you’re feeling stuck or inspired, let’s chat. A short consultation with Total Bath can turn your bathroom dreams into a real-life refresh that you’ll love for years to come.

👇 Helpful Links You’ll Love:

Tub to Shower Conversions

Shower Replacements